In response to
the second prompt, the first two books of the Harry Potter series is a great
example of Iser's argument that “expectations are scarcely ever fulfilled in
truly literary texts.”
In Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone we,
as the reader, are introduced into the world of magic, a world that Harry
himself is for the first time experiencing and we are filled with all kinds of
questions about this magic and its history and social practices. We hold all of the same questions as Harry,
and like-wise expect all of them to be answered. We expect to know why Harry didn't die all
those years ago, and where Voldemort has been sense that night, and why Snape
hates Harry so much, and how come Hermione is such a great wizard born of muggle
parents, and Neville whom is a “pure-blood” can’t seem to do anything right. By the end of the book we are still wondering
about Harrys past, and know next to nothing about Voldemort and where he has
been or if he is coming back. It still
makes little sense as why Hermione is so naturally talented and Neville
struggles so much. There are questions
from every area in this world that are left unanswered and are meant to be that
way. In this series especially the
element of mystery and surprise is what keeps us as readers indulged. However knowing this is a series also gives
us the expectation that these questions will be answered at some point.
When we enter into
book two Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, we are introduced to new characters and new bits of magic that enchant
us all over again. We become more
familiar with our leading characters and ones that were hiding in the
background for most of the first book.
We see How Ron’s bad luck gets him into some sticky (or slimy)
situations, how Hermione cleverness always comes in handy with their
adventures, and Harry, while brave and a true has a knack for being in the
wrong place at the wrong time. The more
we get to know them the more find ourselves caring for these characters. We start to expect things of them, to stay
out of trouble for once, to find out what bad things are happening and be able
to stop it before anyone gets hurt. We
expect that teachers will be on their side and that these three will stick
together through anything they have to face.
We expect that Malfoy is the heir to Slytherin that has opened the
chamber of secrets and is helping attack people in the school. We are surprised to learn in the end that it
was actually little Ginny Weasley who had opened that chamber of secrets, possessed
of course by Voldemort himself. Harry is
there of course to fight Voldemort away again and save poor Ginny before it is
too late. We do get a little more
information on Harry’s past as well as Voldemorts in the final chapters of this
book. We now understand that Voldemort
is the heir to Slytherin and that Harry can speak to snakes because of a
connection he has to Voldemort (one greater than we first expected.)
J.K. Rowling builds
up our expectations and the fails to fulfill them to keep us wanting more, so
keep us wondering and to force us to try and solve the mysteries on our
own. It encourages us
to look at the story lines and all the information given in every way to try
and unravel the mystery knowing we can never be sure until we finish the
series. Fulfilling expectations is not
exciting while failing to answer our most despite of questions is an
intentional action that keeps us coming back.
Megan I love the way you explain Fulfilling expectations as not exciting while failing to answer our most despite of questions is an intentional action that keeps us coming back. It reminds me of my response to the prompt however I love the way that you word your thought there. It gives a great meaning to the question.
ReplyDelete